Join the Pot

Deshaun Watson Should Be Comeback Player of the Year: The Case Over Mahomes and Tank Dell

Deshaun Watson celebrates in his brown No. 4 Browns uniform

Comeback Player of the Year is supposed to be about one thing: how far you had to come back from. Not who had the best season. Not who has the biggest name. How far you fell, and how far you climbed back.

By that standard, nobody in the NFL has a better case right now than Deshaun Watson. Watch my take first, then let me walk you through exactly why.

Where Watson was a year ago

On Oct. 20, 2024, Watson got carted off against the Bengals with a torn right Achilles. He had surgery five days later. Then in January 2025 he ruptured the same Achilles again and needed a second surgery on Jan. 9.

He didn't play a single snap in 2025. Not one.

Before this season, he hadn't played more than seven games in a year since 2020. Most people had him written off as a Brown for good. Instead he went into camp, won the starting job over Shedeur Sanders, and has started nine games this year.

What he's done in 2026

Here's the full line through nine games: 2,118 passing yards, 7 touchdowns, 4 interceptions and an 89.1 passer rating.

I'm going to be straight with you. Those aren't MVP numbers. He's had some ugly first halves, and the Browns have spent way too much time trailing.

But look at what happens when the game is on the line:

  • Six game-winning drives, tied with Denver's Bo Nix for the most in the NFL.

  • A game-winning drive in every one of the Browns' first six wins. He's only the third quarterback since 1970 to do that, joining Troy Aikman in 1990 and Matthew Stafford in 2016.

  • 23 of 29 for 254 yards on those six drives combined.

  • Three straight 300-yard games heading into the bye.

And the team results back it up. Vegas set the Browns' preseason win total at 5.5. They're 6-4, sitting in the AFC's seventh seed, and 4-0 at home for the first time since 1963.

What the award is actually supposed to measure

This matters. Since 2024, the AP has defined the award as going to a player coming back from illness, injury or other circumstances that caused him to miss playing time the previous season.

So the question isn't who's playing best. The question is who came back from the most, and what he did with it.

Why not Patrick Mahomes?

Respect to Mahomes. He tore his ACL and LCL against the Chargers in Week 15 last season and had surgery the next day. Coming back from that is no joke, and he looks like himself again. In Week 10 against Atlanta he threw for 348 yards and five touchdowns, and the Chiefs are 7-2.

But Mahomes played 14 games last season. The injury cost him the final three. Watson missed the entire 2025 season and needed two surgeries on the same tendon to get back.

Mahomes being elite is just Mahomes being Mahomes. That's not a comeback. That's Tuesday. I'm not the only one who feels that way, either. Plenty of fans have been saying it all week.

Why not Tank Dell?

Tank Dell is the one I'd struggle to vote against, and I want to be fair to him. On Dec. 21, 2024, he dislocated his left knee and tore multiple ligaments against the Chiefs. He missed all of 2025. His first catch back this October went for 43 yards, his first reception in 673 days. He followed that with a long touchdown against the Chargers. That's a great story, and I'm rooting for him.

But Dell has played three games. When he came to Cleveland last Sunday, he had three catches for 21 yards. The Texans are 3-6.

Watson has started nine games at the most important position in sports, and he's the reason a team that was supposed to win five or six games is holding a playoff spot in November.

The part people don't want to talk about

I know Watson's history off the field means some people will never want to see his name next to an award. That's their right, and I'm not here to argue with how anybody feels about that.

This case is about football and about the road back from two Achilles surgeries. On that alone, it's not close.

The odds say long shot. The tape says otherwise.

As of Wednesday, Nov. 18, Kalshi's Comeback Player of the Year market has Mahomes at 70%, Tank Dell at 14%, Kirk Cousins at 6% and Watson at 4%, with more than $2.9 million traded. Those numbers swing fast. On Nov. 15 the same market had Mahomes at 53% and Dell at 24%.

He has national believers too. On ESPN's First Take on Oct. 27, Stephen A. Smith said, "Deshaun Watson right now is the Comeback Player of the Year."

The next chance to make his case comes on Nov. 29, when the Raiders come to Cleveland on Sunday Night Football. National TV, the whole country watching, and one more game-winning drive would tie Brian Sipe's Browns record of seven from 1979. If you want to change a voter's mind, that's the stage to do it.

Who you got for Comeback Player of the Year? Let me know in the comments on the video.

Disclosure: I'm a paid Kalshi partner, and the video above includes a sponsored Kalshi segment. Market prices change constantly and aren't a guarantee of anything.


Stay in the CrocPot

If you rock with this, there's a lot more where it came from.

  • Watch: daily Browns takes, live watch parties and postgame reactions on YouTube at @ChefZae. Join the channel for perks.

  • Follow: TikTok @ChefZae, Instagram @ChefZae23, X @Chefzae23, Twitch twitch.tv/chefzae

  • Merch: Get Off The Field, Muni Lot'n, WOOF! and more in the CrocPot Shop.

  • Newsletter: tap "Get takes in your inbox" below this post. You'll get my Browns takes, game-day plans and merch drops first.

Sponsored: Powered by Kalshi. Get $25 when you sign up with Chef Zae: sign up on Kalshi with my code

Sources

Get takes in your inbox