Carson Schwesinger was an unranked recruit who walked on at UCLA. Ten games into his second NFL season, he's third in the league in tackles, he's got three sacks and three forced fumbles, and he hasn't missed a single defensive snap. He's been doing a lot of it on a bad ankle and a taped-up hand.
So let me say it with my whole chest: Carson Schwesinger should be First-Team All-Pro this year. And if he finishes this season the way Luke Kuechly finished his second year, he's going to win Defensive Player of the Year. Maybe not this season, but it's coming. Watch my take first, then I'm going to walk you through every number.
The case in 30 seconds
Production: 102 tackles through 10 games, third in the NFL
Splash plays: 3 sacks and 3 forced fumbles. Among the league's top 15 tacklers, only one player has more sacks
Availability: 658 of 658 defensive snaps, including every game since he sprained his ankle on Oct. 11
Pedigree: reigning AP Defensive Rookie of the Year, on the exact same path Kuechly took
Where he came from
Schwesinger joined UCLA as a walk-on and didn't become a full-time starter until 2024. The Browns took him 33rd overall in 2025, the first pick of the second round, and he made that pick look like a steal right away.
As a rookie he put up 156 tackles, 11 tackles for loss, 2.5 sacks, two interceptions and three passes defensed. He led every rookie in the league in tackles and tackles for loss, played 97% of the defensive snaps and wore the green dot, meaning he was calling the defense in his first year.
He won AP Defensive Rookie of the Year with 40 of 50 first-place votes. Myles Garrett won Defensive Player of the Year the same night, making them the first teammates to win both awards in the same year since Terrell Suggs and Ray Lewis in Baltimore in 2003.
Year two, by the numbers
Here's where he stands after the Texans game:
102 tackles, third in the NFL behind Nakobe Dean and Alex Singleton, who are both at 107
3 sacks, 3 forced fumbles and 6 tackles for loss
Double-digit tackles in six of 10 games
13 tackles, eight solo, in the 27-24 win over Houston. He led the team in both
He's averaging 10.2 tackles a game. And the Browns are 6-4 with him as the guy in the middle of it all.
He's doing it hurt
This is the part people outside Cleveland don't know about, so let's lay out exactly what's been reported.
Oct. 11 at the Jets: he sprained his ankle, a Grade 1 sprain per RotoWire, and left MetLife Stadium in a walking boot. He still finished that game with 8 tackles and a sack.
Ravens week: he missed the first two practices, was limited Friday and was listed questionable. He played anyway.
Oct. 18 vs. Baltimore: he got banged up on the first defensive series and played most of the game with his hand and wrist taped. The Athletic's Zac Jackson posted that he was walking to the x-ray room. All he did was put up 13 tackles, lead everybody on the field and force a Derrick Henry fumble in a 13-10 win.
Nov. 1 vs. Pittsburgh: News 5's Camryn Justice reported he'd been dealing with the ankle for weeks and got extra wrapping on his hand and wrist in the medical tent. He still led the Browns with 10 tackles.
Nov. 15 vs. Houston: he was still on the injury report with wrist and ankle issues. Thirteen tackles.
After the Ravens game, Todd Monken said, "Every time I'd see Carson, and I'd ask him, he would get this silly smirk on his face." Carson's take on his hand? "It didn't affect me, so I assume it's fine." Jared Verse put it best: "He has like an old-school linebacker mindset."
To be clear, he wasn't hurt from Week 1. The ankle goes back to Oct. 11. But he hasn't missed a game or a snap since, with 13, 10 and 13-tackle games along the way.
The All-Pro race: who he's up against
The AP picks two linebackers on the first team and two on the second team. Edge rushers are a separate spot, so Carson isn't competing with guys like Garrett for this one. Last year's picks were Jack Campbell and Jordyn Brooks on the first team, and Devin Lloyd and Ernest Jones IV on the second.
Here's the field right now:
Alex Singleton, Denver: 107 tackles and 2 sacks in nine games. He has the volume edge per game, no question. Carson has more sacks and has played every snap.
Nakobe Dean, Las Vegas: 107 tackles and 1.5 sacks. Carson has twice the sacks, and he gets Dean head to head on Sunday Night Football on Nov. 29.
Ernest Jones IV, Seattle: 98 tackles and 3 sacks. Honestly, this is the closest comp. Same sacks, four fewer tackles, and he made second team last year.
Fred Warner, San Francisco: 88 tackles and half a sack in nine games, but he's tied for the NFL lead with 5 forced fumbles. Warner has the name and the turnovers. Carson has 14 more tackles and 2.5 more sacks.
Jordyn Brooks, Miami: last year's first-teamer is at 84 tackles and zero sacks.
Jack Campbell, Detroit: the other first-teamer from last year isn't even in the top 30 in tackles on NFL.com right now.
Nobody else on that list checks every box. Top-three in tackles, more sacks than anyone near the top of the tackle list except one rookie, three forced fumbles, every snap, and doing it on a bad ankle. If the All-Pro vote were today, he's on the first team for me.
The DPOY race: who he's up against
Now let's be honest about the big one. Will Anderson Jr. is the favorite at around even money. He leads the league with 10.5 sacks through nine games, with 13 tackles for loss and two forced fumbles. Dallas Turner (8 sacks), Fred Warner (5 forced fumbles) and Jeffery Simmons (6 sacks) are behind him.
Here's the thing though. Anderson and Carson were on the same field Sunday. Anderson had 4 tackles and a strip-sack. Carson had 13 tackles. The Browns won.
The bigger problem is history. Since Kuechly won in 2013, every Defensive Player of the Year has been a pass rusher, a defensive tackle or a corner. No off-ball linebacker has won it since. Sports Info Solutions pointed out this week that the award "primarily has gone to a player who came into the season as an All-Pro in a prior season and on a defense that ranks in the top 10 in total defense."
Carson doesn't have either one yet. He wasn't an All-Pro last year, and the Browns are allowing 22 points a game, 13th in the league, and rank 26th against the run.
That's why this year is the All-Pro year. Make First-Team All-Pro in 2026, get this defense back into the top 10, and he walks into 2027 with the exact résumé voters look for. As of Nov. 18 he's +10000 at OddsAssist and +15000 at FanDuel. That's the price on this season. Next year's price is going to look a lot different.
The Kuechly blueprint
This is why the comparison isn't a stretch. Kuechly went to Carolina in 2012, led the NFL with 164 tackles and won Defensive Rookie of the Year. Then in 2013, his second year, he did this:
156 tackles, 2 sacks and 4 interceptions in 16 games
A 24-tackle game against the Saints in Week 16
First-Team All-Pro
Defensive Player of the Year at 22, with 19 of 50 votes to Robert Mathis' 11 1/2
And Kuechly didn't have an All-Pro on his résumé either. He won it anyway, with a defense that backed him up. Carolina allowed 241 points that year, second fewest in the league behind Seattle.
Now put Carson's pace next to it. At 10.2 tackles a game over 17 games, he finishes around 173 tackles, 5 sacks and 5 forced fumbles. That beats Kuechly's 2013 in tackles, sacks and forced fumbles. The one hole is interceptions.
And the two-year number is crazy. Kuechly had 320 tackles in his first two seasons. Carson is at 258 with seven games left. He needs 62 more, under 9 a game, and he's averaging over 10.
What he needs in the last 7 games
If I'm drawing up Carson's checklist, it looks like this:
70 more tackles. That's 10 a game, right at his pace, and it puts him at 172.
81 if he wants to chase the top. That gets him to 183, the league-leading total that put Jordyn Brooks on the first team last year.
Two more sacks. Five sacks is more than Kuechly had in 2013 and more than Brooks had last year.
Two more forced fumbles. That puts him at five, right where Warner is now.
His first interception. Ideally two. Kuechly had four. Devin Lloyd made second-team All-Pro last year with five. Picks are what voters remember.
A signature night. He's got it right there: Raiders on Sunday Night Football, Nov. 29, at home, against Nakobe Dean, who's tied for the league lead in tackles. Win that matchup in front of the whole country and the national guys start paying attention.
Fix the run defense. The Browns are 26th against the run. The middle linebacker gets the credit when that gets fixed, and the blame when it doesn't.
Keep winning. 6-4 is a playoff push. Voters love the best player on a winning defense.
My take
I'm not going to sell you a fake 100-1 ticket and tell you he's winning DPOY this year. Anderson's having a monster season, and pass rushers own this award right now.
But All-Pro? He's earned that conversation today. He's top-three in tackles, he's making plays in the backfield, he's taking the ball away, and he hasn't come off the field while playing hurt. That's a First-Team All-Pro linebacker.
Kuechly went Rookie of the Year, then All-Pro and DPOY in year two. Carson is already halfway there. If he adds the turnovers down the stretch and this defense climbs, the Browns could have back-to-back Defensive Players of the Year from two different guys. Remember who said it first.
Drop your take in the comments. Is Schwesinger an All-Pro this year?
Stay in the CrocPot
Watch: daily Browns takes, live watch parties and postgame reactions on YouTube at @ChefZae. Join the channel for perks.
Follow: TikTok @ChefZae, Instagram @ChefZae23, X @Chefzae23, Twitch twitch.tv/chefzae
Merch: Get Off The Field, Muni Lot'n, WOOF! and more in the CrocPot Shop.
Newsletter: tap "Get takes in your inbox" below this post. You'll get my Browns takes, game-day plans and merch drops first.
Sponsored: Powered by Kalshi. Get $25 when you sign up with Chef Zae: sign up on Kalshi with my code
Sources
Draft, 2025 stats and rookie award: Pro Football Reference and NFL.com
Walk-on story, rookie leader in tackles and TFL, green dot: ClevelandBrowns.com
2026 tackle leaders, sacks for Schwesinger and the other linebackers: NFL.com tackle leaders and Stat Sniper
Schwesinger's forced fumbles: ESPN
Snap count, double-digit games and the Texans game: RotoWire
TFL and Texans week injury report: Browns Nation
Ankle sprain and Ravens week practice report: RotoWire
Jets game, walking boot and Zac Jackson's x-ray report: Browns Nation
Ravens game, Monken, Schwesinger and Verse quotes: cleveland.com via Yahoo Sports
Steelers game and Camryn Justice's report: Browns Nation
2025 All-Pro team and format: NFL.com
Devin Lloyd's 2025 season: Jaguars.com
Jordyn Brooks' 2025 season: Roundtable
DPOY race, Warner's forced fumbles and the SIS quote: Sports Info Solutions
Anderson's season: Sports Betting Dime; Anderson vs. Cleveland: RotoWire
Sack leaders: LeagueLeaders
Browns defense rankings: StatChasers
DPOY odds, Nov. 18, 2026: OddsAssist and FanDuel Research
Kuechly's career stats and awards: Wikipedia, Luke Kuechly and Pro Football Hall of Fame
Kuechly's 2013 vote and Carolina's defense: FOX Sports (AP)
Kuechly's 24-tackle game: NFL.com
Past DPOY winners and positions: AP via WTOP

